Birmingham Cyclist

Cycling in and around Birmingham England

I don't want to get into a debate about the riskiness of cycling over tramlines but can somebody advise what the layout will be when the trams head up to Five Ways?

I'm sure I remember reading that cars won't be allowed down Broad Street so I presume it will be one tram lane and one bus lane. Can anybody confirm?

Views: 465

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

Collecting evidence from the website, current road layout, and the original set up of the bicycle banning on the extension between Snowhill and New Street, its very safe to assume cycling will be banned on both Hill Street and also on Broad Street I am sorry to say. They already made bike bans on Corp Street for cyclists because of the trams.

Attachments:

Birmingham Connected seemed very happy and pleased they banned cyclists on Twitter few months ago. What have they done in the past several years for cyclists? NOTHING!

As to weather cars will be allowed or not I am not sure. I would assume cars will STILL remain as being banned on that section of Broad Street. I would not see why they would reopen it to motor traffic. It would be pretty stupid of the council if they did reopen to cars as they CLAIM they want to get the city to be a more car free area. 

Attachments:

I've ridden the tram route from Stephenson Street to Colmore Row loads of times and will be cycling on Broad Street too. There might be a no cycling sign near the Apple Store but I've never seen it officer I'm very sorry. I'm not sure what the plans for Broad Street are.

This film shows plenty of cyclists, pedestrians walking and riding with trams and tram tracks.

It shows an urban environment that predates dates the car .- in Stockton on Tees 

https://player.bfi.org.uk/free/film/watch-stockton-on-tees-1910-online

And here are some videos by people who also thought they would be just fine.

1) Trams should be running in middle of road (as the old ones used to do) as far as possible on reserved track. If caught earlu enough at the design stage, a case might be made to install vignole section BR113A rail at points where other road traffic crosses, and install a cycle-proof level crossing system, which has practically eliminated cyclist falls on railway crossings - I gather such a crossing on the Wensleydale Railway is saving them c.£10,000/year in insurance excesses for cyclists' claims, and since it was installed 4 years ago they've had just one cyclist fall off, and were not found to be at fault.

2) A robust study of cyclist falls in Toronto, with the TTC's very dense network of tram lines estimated that 85% of cyclists' falls were delivered as a result of another road user causing the cyclist to modify their intended course for crossing the rails or be distracting them at critical moment. Most Dutch riding bikes around tram tracks with no cars or buses to watch for.      

It appears that there is little gap between the rail and the cobbles in the Stockton film; also the tyres were probably wider than many are today.

Doug said:

This film shows plenty of cyclists, pedestrians walking and riding with trams and tram tracks.

It shows an urban environment that predates dates the car .- in Stockton on Tees 

https://player.bfi.org.uk/free/film/watch-stockton-on-tees-1910-online

Baring in mind these are all shared with motor vehicles. As far as I am aware only permitted motor vehicles are allowed up Navigation street. Apart from that, there is nothing that would run you over if you fell/slipped on the tram tracks. BUT its not difficult to ride a long tram tracks. I did it BEFORE they put in the bicycle bans. When you cross your wheels over the tracks, (Do NOT go fast, AND be sure you give a wide angle move. Bassically you need to lean left then lean right to get a more appropriate angel crossing over the tracks. But this information is pointless as cycling along the road is now banned.

Something the Council could have EASILY done was install a central bicycle lane in the middle of the tram line. So cyclists would cycle in the middle. All would of needed was to move the tram tracks over to the side a little more.

Robert said:

And here are some videos by people who also thought they would be just fine.

Reply to Discussion

RSS

Site Sponsors


Latest Activity

Shakey replied to Philip Whiteman's discussion Velo Midland 2018
"Route does not look great and not particularly taxing. I thought last year's velo was perfect…"
17 minutes ago
ian robathan replied to ian robathan's discussion Audax
"ah yeah I saw that one and planning a 600km next year so that is one I am looking at "
3 hours ago
ian robathan replied to Philip Whiteman's discussion Velo Midland 2018
"shame really as all events I have taken part in no issues "
3 hours ago
Andy White replied to ian robathan's discussion Audax
"BCM = Bryan Chapman Memorial (600k and stupid climb) btw ;-)"
13 hours ago
Andy White replied to ian robathan's discussion Audax
"BCM is beyond me now Ian ! I joined Audax 35 years ago and never got past a 600k. PBP 87 was…"
13 hours ago
Kim replied to Philip Whiteman's discussion Velo Midland 2018
"They did last time.  No idea what's happening next year."
yesterday
ian robathan replied to ian robathan's discussion Audax
"The ones I will keep Phil are the early season ones, for example done one from Garden every year…"
yesterday
Philip Whiteman replied to ian robathan's discussion Audax
"Welcome to the dark side. Years ago I too made that transition.  I recall those heady days of…"
yesterday
Andy White replied to ian robathan's discussion Audax
"Welcome to the 'family' and even more TLAs ... BCM, PBP, LEL ... ;-)"
yesterday
James Russell replied to ian robathan's discussion Audax
"I've done the Kidderminster Killer myself.  A lovely day out if you don't mind a bit…"
yesterday
ian robathan posted a discussion

Audax

I will admit until this year I was sniffy about Audaxing, always thought Sportives were better and…See More
Sunday
ian robathan replied to Philip Whiteman's discussion Velo Midland 2018
"apart from TT ones, do they ban say tandems or recumbents then ? "
Saturday
Shakey replied to john butler's discussion Bourne brook pathway
"Fully open again last night although care needed in places as there  is a lot of loose gravel…"
Saturday
Kim replied to Philip Whiteman's discussion Velo Midland 2018
"Or at least those whose bikes aren't arbitrarily banned..."
Saturday
Robert replied to Robert's discussion Carrera GTi
"£200 for a "bike" with a half sawn-through frame (amongst numerous other serious…"
Saturday
Andrew W replied to Robert's discussion Carrera GTi
"It’s currently advertised for sake on Facebook for £200 I’m quite tempted "
Friday

© 2018   Created by LS.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service